I'm a big Harvest Moon fan. I bought my first Harvest Moon game at the age of 13, on a tender whim in a southern California target (this was long before I read game reviews compulsively before buying a game; it's a wonder I didn't buy bad games more often). This particular version of Harvest Moon, was Harvest Moon 64.
I don't exactly recall my first impression of the game (it's been ten years now), but I do remember sitting there for hours, completely entranced with the game. Soon, classmates of mine began thinking I had some home issues, since I could be overheard bragging about having a baby (or rather, my wife Ann had a baby). I was bragging about the fact that all my animals loved me, and I was friends with everyone in town. That's where the true allure of Harvest Moon lay- the subtle, quirky townspeople. Although it was a repetitive game, I delighted in reading "new" dialogue from characters.
Harvest Moon 64 had something special, and I've been looking for it in each subsequent Harvest Moon. The closest "feeling" I got to it was Harvest Moon: Save the Homeland, which came out on the PS2. The characters were just unique enough to keep me interested, and the gameplay wasn't overly-complicated, as some Harvest Moon's have become (Island of Happiness is the worst offender- an otherwise fun game ruined by complex mechanics). The problem? You could get married- one of the greatest things about Harvest Moon was marriage!
Please don't look at me like that. I'm not obsessed with marriage in any way, and I'm certainly not pushing to tie the knot with anyone in real life. But being able to marry the girl of your choice was such a gratifying feature. It may sound cheesy, but I have always enjoyed my Harvest Moon "weddings", and the fact that you could have a child. It is, in a sense, THE goal in Harvest Moon. So taking that aspect out? A total bummer.
Another Harvest Moon game played with the "traditional" Harvest Moon rules, and that was Harvest Moon: A Wonderful Life. Unlike any other Harvest Moon game, your character ages, as does your child and wife. When the concept first came out, I was thrilled.
...I was extremely disappointed. I tried to like the game. I tried to love the game, with all my heart. It's main flaw was thus: it was far too slow. Please consider this: I am a fan of reading the dictionary to learn new words. I work at Disneyland. I knit. And this game was too slow and tedious. In all honesty, the biggest problem was the way time moved: instead of thirty short days, each month is ten long ones. And I'm not kidding around when I say long- each day is like dragging your feet through the mud. In addition to that, there are only three bachorlettes, they are all incredibly easy, and their personalities are boring! I haven't got the slightest clue what it's like when my kid grows up, because I haven't the patience to find out.
Even Magical Melody, which is probably third on my list after 64 and Save the Homeland, has elements of being boring. The overworld is just too big, which makes you waste so much time just running from location to location. Although I remember thinking when I played Harvest Moon 64 that it would be cool to have a bigger place, I've changed my mind. Harvest Moon doesn't need atmospheric grass. It needs shops, people, and animals. If none of those three things apply in any way (including a showing of someone's personality, ie, they like being at the beach at late nights), it doesn't need to be there. Period. I'm also not one to "judge a game by it's graphics", but the style drove me nuts. I played as the female farmer (a mistake; I should have known that wooing the girls would be more fun), and as shallow as this sounds, I couldn't fathom how any of the male characters could think she was pretty. She looked prepubescent.
So Natsume, what I really want is for you to release a revised edition of "Save the Homeland" where you can get married, and there isn't a weird memory wipe at the end of the year. Actually, that would be the perfect Harvest Moon.
Showing posts with label rant. Show all posts
Showing posts with label rant. Show all posts
14 December 2009
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
